Alta Stella, a newly opened constellation-themed luxury restro-bar in Mumbai, has ignited a firestorm of controversy. The venue, co-owned by Bollywood star Sanjay Dutt and entrepreneur Abhimanyu Jakhar, is facing accusations of animal cruelty after videos surfaced showing a live fish being used as a cocktail garnish.
What began as a buzz-worthy launch focused on celestial aesthetics has quickly turned into a public relations nightmare as the “zodiac concept” sparked widespread ethical concerns.
The Controversy: “Cruelty Made Instagrammable”
The outrage stems from images and videos showing a live fish placed directly into a cocktail glass as part of the drink’s presentation. The situation escalated with allegations that in at least one instance, a cocktail was set on fire while the fish remained inside the glass.
Key Points of Outrage:
-
Suffocation & Stress: Activists pointed out that fish do not die quickly when removed from water or placed in foreign liquids; they can suffer for up to 24 minutes while slowly suffocating.
-
Ethical Standards: Critics are questioning the responsibility of high-end luxury establishments to maintain ethical standards, even when pursuing “creative” or “aesthetic” presentations.
-
Exploitation for Content: Many social media users have slammed the practice as a “cheap trick” designed to gain traction on platforms like Instagram at the expense of a living creature.
Social Media Backlash
The reaction across platforms has been swift and severe. Users, animal welfare advocates, and influencers who previously promoted the bar are now calling for accountability.
“This is not a theme. This is cruelty. This is not creativity. This is cruelty made Instagrammable… Normalizing their exploitation as entertainment is a dangerous step backwards.” — Viral Instagram Caption
Direct User Reactions:
-
“Why don’t y’all put yourselves into fish tanks and swim around for your customers… They will pay a lot more to watch that.”
-
“Seriously? You’re contributing to the suffering of innocent creatures now because your decor options are exhausted?”
Current Status
While Alta Stella initially gained fame for its high-end bar experience and celestial theme, the brand’s reputation is currently shadowed by this incident. There is a growing demand from the public for the management—and its high-profile owners—to address the practice and ensure that living beings are no longer used for “aesthetic” entertainment.
